Yeah I give them, but its not common for me to hand them out haha the book has to really work for me in every way. And yeah I do feel like readers give them out way too often. But it depends on the reader too. Sometimes I think people are too nit picky as well LOL
I can see it going both ways. I try to keep my 5's for those blow away books. I'm don't like stars because I can have some issues with a story and still think it's good. Like is all about issues.